Choose how you’d like to reach a resort specialist.
Secrets St. Lucia Resort & Spa
Contact: +1 (888) 605-1350
Best for couples and adults who want a premium Unlimited-Luxury® all-inclusive experience in St. Lucia with stunning Caribbean views, world-class spa, gourmet dining, and a romantic adults-only atmosphere.
Better for travelers who want a more affordable, locally-owned St. Lucia beachfront resort with a relaxed Caribbean vibe, family-friendly options, and easy access to Rodney Bay Village dining and nightlife.
If you want a luxury adults-only all-inclusive with premium inclusions and a romantic atmosphere, Secrets St. Lucia Resort & Spa is typically the better pick—especially for couples who value Unlimited-Luxury® amenities, gourmet dining, a world-class spa, and an elevated resort experience.
If your priority is a more budget-friendly St. Lucia beach vacation with local Caribbean charm, Bay Gardens Beach Resort & Spa usually comes out ahead—particularly for travelers who want family-friendly options, a prime Reduit Beach location, and easy access to Rodney Bay restaurants and shops.
Bottom line: choose Secrets St. Lucia for a romantic, all-inclusive luxury escape with everything included, and choose Bay Gardens for a laid-back, value-oriented St. Lucia stay with more flexibility and local flavor.
| Category | Secrets St. Lucia Resort & Spa | Bay Gardens Beach Resort & Spa |
|---|---|---|
| Overall Vibe |
Luxury adults-only Unlimited-Luxury® all-inclusive with romantic ambiance, premium amenities, and an elevated resort experience in Rodney Bay.
Best for Romance
|
Locally-owned beachfront resort with Caribbean charm, a relaxed pace, and family-friendly options on popular Reduit Beach.
Best for Value
|
| Location | Oceanfront setting in northern St. Lucia near Rodney Bay, with stunning Caribbean Sea views and easy access to local attractions. | Prime location directly on Reduit Beach in Rodney Bay Village, walking distance to restaurants, bars, and shopping. |
| Rooms & Suites | Luxurious suites with ocean views, premium bedding, swim-out options, and Preferred Club upgrades for enhanced service and amenities. | Comfortable rooms and suites with Caribbean décor, many with ocean or pool views—ideal for budget-conscious travelers and families. |
| Dining | Multiple gourmet restaurants included, 24-hour room service, premium spirits, and no reservations required—true Unlimited-Luxury® dining. | On-site dining with Caribbean and international options; optional all-inclusive plan available, plus easy access to Rodney Bay Village restaurants. |
| Pools & Beach | Elegant infinity pools, private cabanas, and a beautiful beach setting designed for relaxation and romance. | Beachfront pools on Reduit Beach with a more casual, lively atmosphere—great for families and water sports enthusiasts. |
| Spa & Wellness | World-class Secrets Spa by Pevonia® with hydrotherapy, couples treatments, and a full wellness menu—a major resort highlight. | La Mer Spa offers relaxing treatments at a more accessible price point, though smaller in scale than Secrets. |
| Price & Value | Higher price point but everything is included—dining, drinks, tips, activities, and spa hydrotherapy. Best value for all-inclusive seekers. | More affordable nightly rates with flexible meal options. Best value for travelers who prefer dining out or want budget flexibility. |
Rooms and suites at Secrets St. Lucia Resort & Spa are designed for romance and luxury, featuring elegant Caribbean décor, premium amenities, and stunning ocean views throughout the property.
Secrets is the better pick if you want a truly luxurious suite experience with everything included and an adults-only romantic atmosphere.
Bay Gardens Beach Resort & Spa offers comfortable, Caribbean-style accommodations that feel welcoming and authentic, with a focus on value and beachfront convenience.
If you want a solid beachfront room without the premium price tag, Bay Gardens delivers Caribbean comfort at a more accessible rate.
Dining at Secrets St. Lucia is a true Unlimited-Luxury® experience, with multiple gourmet restaurants, premium spirits, and 24-hour dining all included in your stay.
Expect:
Bay Gardens Beach Resort offers on-site dining with Caribbean flair, plus the flexibility to explore Rodney Bay Village's many restaurants just steps away.
If you want flexibility to dine out and explore local restaurants, Bay Gardens' location gives you the best of both worlds.
Secrets St. Lucia features elegant infinity pools and a pristine beach setting designed for couples who want a serene, romantic atmosphere with premium service.
Bay Gardens Beach Resort sits directly on famous Reduit Beach, one of St. Lucia's most popular stretches of sand with a more lively, social atmosphere.
If you want a livelier beach scene with water sports and easy access to beach bars, Bay Gardens' Reduit Beach location is hard to beat.
The Secrets Spa by Pevonia® at Secrets St. Lucia is a world-class wellness destination, offering couples treatments, hydrotherapy circuits, and an extensive menu of luxurious services.
La Mer Spa at Bay Gardens offers relaxing treatments at accessible prices, providing a nice spa option without the premium luxury resort cost.
If spa is a major priority for your trip, Secrets St. Lucia's world-class Secrets Spa is in a different league entirely.
Secrets St. Lucia Resort & Spa offers the most value when you want everything included in one upfront price—gourmet dining, premium drinks, spa hydrotherapy, tips, and activities.
Bay Gardens Beach Resort & Spa is the better value if your priorities are lower nightly rates, flexibility, and the freedom to explore local St. Lucia dining.
Choose Secrets if you want an adults-only romantic escape with Unlimited-Luxury® inclusions, world-class spa, and a truly special couples' experience.
Bay Gardens is the better pick for families and value-seekers who want a prime Reduit Beach location without luxury all-inclusive pricing.
For spa enthusiasts and wellness-focused travelers, Secrets St. Lucia's world-class Secrets Spa with included hydrotherapy is unmatched.
If you want to explore Rodney Bay Village restaurants and nightlife, Bay Gardens' walkable location puts you right in the heart of the action.
Questions? Contact Us!
